Category: Religion

  • Pertinent Information on the Great Courses DVD lectures on The Catholic Church: A History

    The DVDs.

               The following are the subjects of each of the 30-minute long lectures

    Disc 1

    1.  From Jesus to the Creation of the Church
    2. The First Christian institutions
    3. Christianities in the Early Church
    4. Persecution and Saints
    5. Peace between Empire and Church
    6. Institutional and Doctrinal Developments

    Disc 2

    7. Latin Theology, Including Augustine

    8. Popes and Bishops in the Early Middle Ages

    9. Monasticism- Benedict and His Rule

    10. Evangelizing Northern and Eastern Europe

    11.The Germanization of Christianity

    12. Charlemagne an the Church in Feudal Times

    Disc 3

    13. Monks and Hermits – New forms of Monasticism

    14. Papal reforms and Church State Controversies

    15. Crusades, Heresy, inquisition

    16. The Papacy – Innocent to Boniface VIII

    17. Francis, Dominic, and the Mendicants

    18. Flowering of Church Art in the Middle Ages

      Disc 4

      19. Scholastic Thought

      20. Medieval Mysticism

      21. The Great Schism and the Conciliar Age

      22. The Renaissance Church

      23. Luther, Calvin, and the Reformation

      24. Catholic Responses – The Council of Trent

        Disc 5

        25. The Jesuits

        26. Catholicism in Asia and the New World

        27. American Catholicism

        28. The Church in the Ages of Reason

        29. Pius IX and Papal Infallibility

        30. Leo XIII and the Modern world

        Disc 6

        31. The Eastern Catholic Churches

        32. The Second Vatican Council

        33. The Catholic Church Looks Outward

        34. The Challenges of New Theologies

        35. John Paul II and the 21st-Century Church

        36. One? Holy? Catholic? Apostolic?

        The Lecturer (The following is from the back of the DVD case)

        “Professor William R. Cook has taught thousands of students for more than 35 years at the State University of New York at Geneseo, where he is Distinguished Teaching Professor of History.  Professor Cook is an expert in Medieval history the Renaissance and Reformation periods, and the Bible and Christian thought. The Medieval Academy of America awarded Professor William R Cook the CARA Award for Excellence in the Teaching of Medieval Studies for his achievements.”

        This course, as with most others, also comes with a course guide book which will be covered in the next blog that I do on the great courses. I have observed that with at least some courses, you can also purchase a bound printed copy of the transcript.

      1.                       Great Courses on Religion with a Catholic Leaning

        The two Courses I would suggest on this topic are:

        1. The Catholic Church: A History.
        2. The History of Christianity: From the Disciples to the Dawn of the Reformation

                 The first is a broad overview covering all of catholic history from the time of Christ to the reign of pope John Paul II.

                 The second course is more or less an in-depth history lesson, with the lecturer emphasizing the things one must keep in mind when examining a subject of this sort. It covers next the cultural contexts, then the birth of Christianity through the beginnings of reform.

                 They give a look at Catholic history from the perspectives of 2 lectures from the time of Christ to the reformation and from just one lecturer from the time of the reformation until the early 2000s.

                 Though I started watching some of the “The Catholic Church: A History,” first, upon starting to watch ”The History of Christianity: From the Disciples to the Dawn of the Reformation,” I feel it would be better to watch it first to see the things one must keep in mind when examining a things concerning the Catholic Church as well as any other religion from a historical perspective to maximize the impact of the content, especially in assessing/finding the pertinent religious content and discovering the important parts of the religious perspective.

                 The next 3 blogs concerning the Great courses (which will be punctuated by a movie review and a partial book review) will go in-depth as to the content of each of these lecture, enumerating the subjects of each lecture as well as some background on each of the lecturers.

      2. Salvations Climax Summarized

                The last 3 blogs spoke about the last supper, the passion and crucifixion at calvary and the Ascension. The last thing that should be mentioned is Pentecost. In the Old Testament, God the Father interacted with man directly, communicating with him, punishing him, rewarding him and giving prophets the information that He would be sending a messiah to save them from the punishment due to original sin, which they promptly transmitted to the people of Isreal. The information on the Messiah was detailed (see the book of the prophet Isaiah) so that Isreal would know when Salvation had come but unfortunately, they were a stiff-necked people (Exodus 32:9, Jeremiah 17:23 and Acts 7:51) and either refused to see the signs that Jesus Christ was the Messiah or ignored the signs through pride!

                Of all the people that had ever lived only one was clearly predicted to come over 600 years before he was born, and that person was Jesus Christ.  In the New Testament, Jesus Christ, God Himself, came to fulfill the law (Matthew 5:17-20) that priest of old had been transmitting to the Jewish people. The priests of the Old Jewish religion were selected by God the Father using the natural law, i.e. the sons of Levi for priests and the sons of Aaron for the high priest. In the New Testament the priest and bishops were selected by supernatural law, by decisions by bishops or Christ Himself in the case of St. Paul which had to be “ratified” by someone who was a disciple and had presumably through at least the sacrament of confirmation if not Holy Orders (on reception of the Spirit being a prerequisite to full service to God see Acts 8:15-17)  had received the Spirit (the first 13 being the 11 apostles who chose the 12th Matthias in Acts 1:15-26 – a decision by the bishops for a successor to Judas Iscariot, and St. Paul, selected supernaturally by the risen Christ from heaven but ratified by a disciple Ananias, see acts 9:10-18, presumably blessed by the apostles to be the equivalent of a priest in those days sometimes referred to a Presbyter in the Douey-Rhiems version of the bible the first English translation of the Vulgate bible, the first produced by the first printing press).

               The reason for the implementation of a supernatural law to select priest and, with the advent of New Testament times, senior priests was two-fold: 1) to enable God to select non-Jews or gentiles to be priests in his religion and 2) Since gentiles of everywhere, other than the place Isreal has always been, He wanted a religion that was “portable,” where a church or diocese could be anywhere even another planet.  This is why even the idea that dogma/doctrine that is solid can even change is so ridiculous.  If man travels to the other side of the galaxy or even universe, how do the get news of that dogma/doctrine has changed?  The same with the holy sacrifice of the mass (the Sunday ritual worship of the Roman Catholic religion), if it is always done and transmitted in Latin, it is a common language neither the rich nor poor can lay claim too and can keep the meaning of dogma constant and unconfused. No matter how language changes, if we assume the speed of light is the limiting factor for information transmission, changes in ritual or clarification of dogma will still insure the “old dogma” is not wrong.  Almighty God planned it this way and why everything in the Old and New Testament is infallibly transmitted and meaning is constant and unchanging.

                 Many non-Catholic Christians, who follow Christ’s philosophy, appear to have problem’s with the fact that Christ might leave some visible authority who’s power is tracable back to God, specifically Jesus Christ.  They appear to think that to pick up a bible, learn it then preach it gives them the authority of a true representative of Christ which of course only a priest or bishop selected through apostolic succession/selection is. Hebrews 9:11,24-25 reads:

        “But Christ being come an high priest of the good things to come, by a greater and more perfect tabernacle not made with hand, that is, not of this creation: . . . For Jesus is not entered into the holies made with hands, the patterns of the true: but into heaven itself, that He may appear now in the presence of God for us.

        Nor yet that he should offer himself often, as the high priest entereth into the holies, every year with the blood of others:”

        Because the bible talks exclusively of Christ as the high priest, people reading the Bible take this to mean he is the only priest, priests having to be consecrated by some authorities are not self-selecting.  The fact is that if  he is indeed the high priest, not the only priest, which is not something He said, then it is implied that He has other priests working for him as the “high priest.” Also, a priest’s function is to offer sacrifice but they hold that Christ sacrifice was all that was needed and made total restitution for our sins, which is true, but at the last the supper saying “do this in remembrance of me” meant to renew the power of Calvery through this union with the original sacrifice to continually draw power for the forgiveness of sins from that sacrifice. The Catholic Church is clear on this point, each mass is not a new sacrifice, it is the self-same sacrifice, to be pulled throughout time to renew the power of this sacrifice, through the remembrance that was asked for by Christ at the last supper.

                Many so called Christians as mentioned above question the churches authority and whether or not priests might still exist (in the bible New Testament presbyters and bishops, which are mentioned are the Catholic Churches names for those officiating at Christs remembrances as replacements for priest and the high priest, so instead of having one temple in one place, each dioceses can have a head official like the former high priest – of which there is still only one, Jesus Christ, who in turn has priests under him), as if God, ever in the Old Testament did not have priests. But Christ said I have not come to abolish the law but to fulfil it in Matthew 5:17. If this is so and if and entire book of the Old Testament Pentateuch, the most holy 5 books of the Jewish religion is dedicated to the ritual and priest – Leviticus, why would he abolish the priesthood, and the fact that they must be selected by some law God (in this case Jesus Christ through His apostles) put into place, in the New Testament? Plus, if Jesus Christ changed anything from the Old Testament he made it stricter and explicit such as the definition of the sin of adultery:  “I say, anyone who even looks at a woman with lust has already committed adultery with her in his heart.” (Matthew 5:28-29)  Also, similarly his injunction on divorce and remarriage when the spouse is not dead is adultery (Matthew 19: 3-9). Everyone is always looking for loopholes for things that are not easy, so to go harder is always a better bet, and if allowed to interpret the bible any way they want, they may interpret it wrong to their everlasting regret! Unfortunately, they must interpret it all correctly to attain salvation!  But that is what the tradition of the Church and the fathers of the church (great Catholics in the first 400 years of the church) are for.

               This is why the keeping of tradition (“Therefore, brethren, stand fast; and hold the traditions which you have learned, whether by word, or by our epistle.” – 2 Thessalonians 2:14) is so important. As complex a problem as keeping the Barque/ship of Peter (a popular symbolic representation of the Roman Catholic Religion within the Catholic Church) on the right course to heaven, tradition becomes very important.  Just like a nuclear submarine (if we use this to symbolically represent the Catholic Religion), when built, is accompanied by a manual (this being like the Bible).  The builders wrote the manual, (Jesus Christ – God) also trained the first crew.  This original crew (which is equivalent to the original apostles) learned tricks to run the submarine which became tradition, which one crew passed on to the next when they left through reassignment or retirement.  If It’s important to ensure that a machine that could do incredible damage to the entire world have experienced people pass on the secrets to its efficient operation, how much more important is it to put into place a cadre of professionals to pass on the hard learned secrets to salvation for each and every man’s immortal soul from generation to generation?

                Some things that come to mind when I think of people rebelling against Gods appointed authority in the Old Testament are the respect David had for the ruling king Saul as God’s anointed one in the first and second books of Samuel as well as the rebellion of Korah and 250 followers who said Moses and Aaron were not above the congregation in authority as high priest etc.  God opened up the earth and swallowed them to prove the authority of Moses and Aaron as we see in the of Numbers chapter 16. Others were not convinced (as seen in the same chapter) and as a result 14,700 Israelites died before the rest of the Israelites got the message loud and clear. Finally, Moses’ own sister Miriam challenged his authority in chapter 12 of the book of Numbers chapter 12 and as a punishment contracted leprosy.

               God always leads his people through people He selects, either by natural law or by supernatural law, which in our case is seen in the apostolic succession/selection (see Acts 1:15-26 that this was sanctioned that they should select successors).  Those who pick up a bible and start to preach, should remember this.  God chooses his representative, they are sent by Him, His representatives don’t select themselves.

               But how can people now be thought to represent God? Because as spoke of earlier they are lead by the Holy Ghost, the third Person of the blessed Trinity – that is God, sent first on the last event of salvations climax, Pentecost, to the apostles (as promised by Jesus Christ in John 14:16-17).  They in turned passed it to their successors, for the purpose of the priesthood/episcopate through the sacrament of Holy Orders.  Rank and file Catholics are passed the Holy Ghost in different a way, with out the power to consecrate the bread and wine in mass to make it the body and blood of Jesus Christ, or to forgive sins (God alone can forgive sins  as supported by Matthew 9:2-8 and Mark 2:7, but if the power is delegated to someone in cooperation with the Holy Ghost as in John 20:19-23, then sins can be forgive by God the Holy Ghost through his representative the priest or bishop).        In the climax to salvation the apostles are given the Eucharist to be able to increase grace in all men and the ability to forgive all sins, but most notably mortal sin (1 John 5:17), to be able to save their souls from eternal damnation should the devil’s wiles succeed in making a man or woman fall hard!

      3. Jesus Death on Calvery

                   Jesus’ death on Calvery is the culminating event of the Jewish religion, even if they don’t admit recognizing it as such.  Many Jewish Rabbis, as I understand, rarely speak of one chapter of the book of the prophet Isaiah because it so clearly identifies Christ by how badly he is treated and related to by people of his time. He is the Messiahs they have spent their whole history preparing for.  The fact is some books in the bible said that the God of the Jews would one day be great among the gentiles, and the relegation of Jews to just another race among the world instead of the “chosen” people rubbed them the wrong way.  But the fact that this happened was the fault of the Jews not recognizing Him when He came and venerating Him as they should have.

                  Jesus’ death is what made restitution to God for all of mankind for the offense of the original sin!

      4. Books on the End Times – Eschatology

        The first book is one based on a series of lectures and is recommended by Saint Therese of Lisieux who said “Reading this book was one of the greatest graces of my life.” The name of the book is “The End of the Present World and the Mysteries of the Future Life” by Father Charles Arminjon.

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ 1933184388

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sophia Institute Press (January 26, 2009)

        Paperback ‏ : ‎ 336 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 9781933184388

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1933184388              

        The next book is “The Apocalypse Explained” by H.M. Feret. O.p.

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B000GARCZ0

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Catholic Media Apostolate; First Edition (January 1, 1958)

        ISBN ‏ : ‎0-912141-69-7

        Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 273 pages

        Nihil obstat: Hubertus Richards, S.T.L., L.S.S.

                            Censor deputatus

        Imprimatur: E. Morrogh Bernard

                           Vic. Gen.

        Westmonasterii. Die 15a Martii, 1958

        The last book is technical at a high level and is called “Eschatology or The Catholic Doctrine of the Last Things: A dogmatic Treatise” by Rt. Rev. Msgr. Joseph Pohle, Ph.D., D.D.  the identification is for a newer reprint and the Nihil Obstat and Imprimatur are from my 1929 Sixth Edition from the B. Herder Book Company, St. Louis, Mo.

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Legare Street Press (September 9, 2021)

        Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 182 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 101356202X

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1013562020

        Nihil obstat: Sti. Ludovici, die 2, Maii, 1929.

                            Joannes Rothensteiner,

                            Censor Librorum

        Imprimatur: Sti. Ludovici, die 3, Maii, 1929.

                           +Joannes J. Glennon

                             Archiepiscopus

      5. Easter Sunday

        Wrote this early, as I do a lot of my posts, and will probably attend midnight mass.  This is to remined us of the importance of Easter Sunday.  On this day, the human race was saved by Jesus Christ, after being convicted of the original sin of Adam and Eve against the all-good God the Father, and given the promise that the punishment that the human race inherited from its first parent’s original sin (both the spiritual damage to our souls that made humans tend toward evil and the eternal punishment of hell) would be not only forgiven, but all those who loved and obeyed His Son would be made adopted sons and daughters of God.

        On this day God the Son the second person of the blessed Trinity rose from the dead after 3 days in the grave proving He was God and had the power to deliver on His promise of eternal life and sonship and daughtership to God the Father (the first person of the blessed Trinity), with the help of the Holy Ghost (the third person of the blessed Trinity) humans that would follow his commandments and love God as they aught with their whole being. The humans that would follow His commandments would be Jesus’ friends and adopted brothers and sisters to enjoy the happiness that would otherwise only be enjoyed only by God Himself.

        Watched an excellent animation at the movie theaters by Angel Studios called the King of Kings which I think did a fairly complete job of explaining Easter and will try to give a review next week.

      6. Books on Apologetics

        The best most concise clear and complete apologetics book, with regard to the Roman catholic religion, I have read, is “Wisdom Shall Enter” by Leo Trese

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0007FP37S

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Fides; 2nd edition (January 1, 1960)

        Paperback ‏ : ‎ 127 pages

        Nihil Obstat: Andreas Moore, L.C.L.

                             Censor Deputatus

        Imprimatur: +Georgius L. Craven

                           Epus. Sebastopolis V.G.

        Westmonasterii die 17a Septemb. 1957

        A Good book for high school students is “Catholic Apologetics: God, Christianity and the Church” by Father John Laux, M.A.

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ TAN Books; First Edition (August 1, 2003)

        Paperback ‏ : ‎ 168 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0895553945

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0895553942

        Reading age ‏ : ‎ 12 – 18 years

        Grade level ‏ : ‎ 10 and up

        Nihil Obstat: Arthur J. Scanlan, S.T.D.

                            Censor Librorum

        Imprimatur: + Patric Cardinal Hayes

                             Archbishop of New York                      August 27, 1928

      7. Books on The Liturgical Year

        There are 3 recommendations I have for anyone wanting to read up on any particular Sunday, Celebration etc. of the Liturgical Year. One is a long concise book, one is a five book set and the final is a 15 book set where each mass is meticulously set out.

        The first is “Goffine’s Devout Instructions on the Epistles and Gospels” by Reverend Father Leonard Goffine, copyright 1896 by Benziger Brothers, New York.

        Nihil Obstat: Thomas L. Kinkead,

                              Censor Librorum

        Imprimatur: Michael Augustine,

                             Archbishop of New York

        New York, April 29, 1896

        It was re-published under the title “The Church’s Year” in 1999

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sarto House; 2nd edition (January 1, 1999)

        Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 814 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0963903241

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0963903242

        Imprimatur: +J.B. Purcell

                             Archbishop of Cincinnati, OH

        Cincinnati, OH (March 26, 1874)

                           +Jos. Dwenger

                             Bishop of Ft. Wayne, IN

        Ft. Wayne, IN (March 26, 1874)

                           +S.H. Rosecranz

                            Bishop of Columbus, OH

        Columbus, OH (June 18, 1874)

        The second set of 5 volumes is entitled “The Church’s Year of Grace” by Dr. Pius Parsch, published by the Order of St. Benedict, Inc., Collegeville Minnesota, available from Amazon.

        Volume 1 – Advent to Candlemas, published May 1959, Imprimatur: September 30, 1957

        Volume II – Septuagesima to Holy Saturday, published 1964, Imprimatur: January 14, 1953

        Volume III – Easter to Pentecost, published April 1963, Imprimatur: September 26, 1953

        Volume IV – June, July, August, published February 1962, Imprimatur: August 1, 1959

        Volume V – September, October, November, published August 1958 Imprimatur: August 22, 1958

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0CJQL9NXL

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ The Liturgical Press (January 1, 1964)

        Nihil obstat: John Eidenschink, O.S.B., J.C.D.

                              Censor Deputatus

        Imprimi Potest: +Baldwin Dworschak, O.S.B.

                                      Abbot of St. John’s Abbey

        Imprimatur: +Peter W. Bartholome, D.D.,

                                 Bishop of St. Cloud

        Finally the classic 15 volume set “The Liturgical Year” by Dom Prosper Gueranger O.S.B.

        Though no official imprimatur, it has an introduction by Henry Edward, the Archbishop of Westminster.

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Loreto Publications; Unexpurgated Original Text edition (November 28, 2013)

        Paperback ‏ : ‎ 7500 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 1622920848

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1622920846

      8. Books on Mary

              In the sequence I have laid out of books to read, the only persons explicitly named are: Jesus Christ and his mother, the Queen Mother of heaven, Mary.  Many protestant sects down play the significance of Mary, the mother of God.  Do they think that Jesus Christ will take kindly to the slighting of His mother on the last day?  We who, as we should be, are respectful of out mothers, due to the 4th commandment (Honor they father and thy mother), how much more does God the Son honor this commandment of His Father with respect also to his Virgin Mother, to the extent that he would die, one of the most excruciating death possible, because it was part of the Father’s plan for man’s salvation.  God has logically given us 2 examples for how to live our lives because in the beginning “male and female He created them” (Genesis 1:27).  He gave us the perfect male example in Jesus Christ and, unlike what I have read of Muslims, who consider women in the same class as animals because if one walks directly in front of you while praying, as with a dog, or a donkey your prayers are invalidated, He also gave human females a perfect example in the Blessed Virgin Mary.  This is not to say anything our Lord does, does not form the perfect example also to women, it merely means that to have a clearer example in things exclusive to women, Mary most easily and in context shows the example (i.e. being a good wife, being a good daughter, being a good female consecrated virgin).

            The first book is possibly the best compilation of essays on the Blessed Virgin compiled by one of my favorite authors – Frank Sheed, and is entitled “The Mary Book” published by Sheed and Ward. It is from this book that I gleamed the emphasis in the other books in this list from its Assembler’s Note and decided to buy them.

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0000CHQTJ

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sheed & Ward; First American Edition (January 1, 1950)

        Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 409 pages

        Nihil obstat: Patricius Morris, S.T.D., L.S.S.,

                               Censor Deputatus

        Imprimatur: E. Morrogh Bernard,

                               Vic. Gen.

        Westmonasterii, die 16a Junii, 1950

             If you want a good book with respect specifically to the Immaculate Conception, you can find it in a Chapter in a book entitled “Our Lady of Wisdom” by Maurice Zundel. It used versions are sometimes available on amazon.
        ASIN ‏ : ‎ 
        B0042LIM3U

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sheed & Ward (January 1, 1941)

        Nihil Obstat: Arthur J. Scanlan, S.T.D.

                             Censor Liborum

        Imprimatur: +Francis J. Spellman, D.D.

                           Archbishop, New York

        New York, August 2, 1940

             For the profound meaning underlying “Our Lady of Sorrows” is a book by the same name by Charles Journet available from amazon.

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B00NPKY9D6

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sheed & Ward; First American edition (January 1, 1938)

        Nihil Obstat: H.E. Calnan

                               Censor Deputatus

        Imprimatur: Can. S. Banfi

                           Vic. Gen.

        Southwarci Die 22 Aprillis 1938

             To get a feeling on how Our Lady’s life had a bearing upon our lives here and now of the period between the Annunciation and Christmas one should read Caryll Houselander’s “Reed of God.” The following is identification information of a recent reprint but the approbations are from my 1944 copy.

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Christian Classics; Revised edition (May 29, 2020)

        Paperback ‏ : ‎ 192 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0870612409

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0870612404

        Nihil Obstat: Arthur J. Scanlan, S.T.D.

                             Censor Liborum

        Imprimatur: +Francis J. Spellman, D.D.

                           Archbishop, New York

        New York, January 10, 1944

              With regard to the growth of Catholic devotion to Our Lady, “Our Blessed Lady: Sermons” by Father C.C. Martindale, S.J., once again sometimes available from amazon.  

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B00085MO60

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sheed & Ward (January 1, 1938)

        De Licentia Superiorium Ordinis

        Nihil Obstat: Georgius Can: Smith, S.TH.D., P.H.D.

                             Censor Deputatus

                             Vic. Gen.

        Westmonasterii, Die 17a Januarii, 1938

             The next book has good information on the doctrine of our lady in the first five centuries and her appearances in the modern world among other good information. It is also available in its original French under the title “La Vierge Marie.” The English title is “The Virgin Mary” by Jean Guitton. Once again sometimes available from amazon

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0007DUSCA

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Kenedy & Sons (January 1, 1952)

        Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 190 pages

        Nihil Obstat: Ricardvs Roche S.T.D..

                             Censor Deputatus

        Imprimatvr: +Joseph

                           Archiepiscopvs Birmingamiensis Birmingamiae: Die XI  AVGVSTI MCMLI

        The second to last book was compiled by Raphael Brown and is entitled “The Life of Mary as seen by the Mystics.” Once again the Imprimatur etc. are from my 1991 copy with this being a newer reprint from the same publisher.

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ TAN Books (November 1, 1991)

        Paperback ‏ : ‎ 284 pages

        ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0895554364

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0895554369

         Nihil Obstat: John A. Schulien, S.T.D.

                              Censor Librorum

        Imprimatur: +Moses E. Kiley

                             Archbishop of Milwaukee                      June 8, 1951

        To complete the set of books that are good to read, in my opinion, on the virgin Mary is one on the technical level, one on Mariology. Mariology is that part of Dogmatic Theology which treats  of the Blessed Virgin Mary , the Mother of our Divine Redemer. The book is entitled “Mariology” by Rt. Rev. Msgr. Joseph Pohle, Ph.D., D.D.. Once again, as in some of my earlier book lists the identify information is for a newer reprint while the Imprimatur etc. are for my earlier 1957 reprint with a 1914 copyright with the B. Herder Book Co.

        ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0BKN5XHY1

        Publisher ‏ : ‎ Independently published (October 26, 2022)

        Hardcover ‏ : ‎ 170 pages

        ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 979-8360449447

        Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 14-4326      

        Nihil Obstat: Sti. Ludovici, die 27 Aug., 1930

                            Joannes Rothensteiner ,

                            Censor Librorum,

        Imprimatur: Sti. Ludovici, die 28 Aug., 1930

                            Patricius Paulus Crane, V.G.

        The questions concerning the Blessed Virgin are so complex and mixed with emotion I have only included books with official approbations. The mother of our Lord is deserving of much love, in that her assent was responsible for our Lord’s coming, but absolutely not more than our Lord himself.