Tag: book review

  • Pamphlet Review of “The Truth About Catholics” and a Prayer in it, by a Protestant, Not Mentioning Catholicism but Asking for the Help from God to Find the One True Faith given by God to Man. 

    Pamphlet Review of “The Truth About Catholics” and a Prayer in it, by a Protestant, Not Mentioning Catholicism but Asking for the Help from God to Find the One True Faith given by God to Man. 

    The pamphlet carries the Imprimatur of the Most Rev. John J. Cantwell, D.D., Bishop of Los Angeles and San Diego. It is the new edition of 1 March 1936.

    It is a basic Catholic apologetics pamphlet both defending and explaining various basic Catholic doctrines and dogmas.  The table of contents is as follows

    A Protestant Prayer [quoted below]                                      1

    Church or Bible                                                                       2

    Questions and Answers, Masonary, K.C. Oath                      4-5

    Why Be a Catholic                                                                    6

    The Visble Church                                                                    7

    The Rosary Explained                                                           10

    Confession                                                                   11

    Purgatory                                                                              12

    Adoration of Mary                                                                                      13

    Catholic Countries Unprogressive                                        14

    Why Priests do not Marry                                                                                     14

    Protestant Marriages                                                           15

    Departure of Non-Catholic Bodies from Apostolic Teaching  16

    History of Sects                                                                                         20

    The Bible an Authority only in Catholic Hands                                                                  21

    Which Guide Would You Take?                                                                                       28

    Abstract of Title from St. Peter to Present Pope [list of Popes from Peter to now]   29

    Is the Catholic Church the Church of the Ignorant [famous converts from the 30s] 32

    Modern Minds Shall Pass Away, But –                                  Back cover

    Catholic Beliefs [hopefully next blog – what Catholics DON’T and DO Believe] Back cover

    I will be publishing articles for this pamphlet, hopefully, intermittently, in the coming weeks, with the titles mentioned in the table of contents above being part of the blog titles, hopefully letting reader know when I do so.

    The prayer for guidance into Truth composed by Mr. Henry Mayer while a Protestant is as follows:

    God of all goodness, almighty and eternal, father of mercies and Savior of mankind!  I implore Thee by Thy sovereign goodness, to enlighten my mind and to touch my heart, that by means of true faith, hope and charity, I may live and die in the true religion of Jesus Christ. I confidently believe that, as there is but one Bod, there can be but one faith, one religion, one only path to salvation, and that every other path opposed thereto can lead to Perdition.  This path, O my God! I anxiously seek after, that I may follow it and be saved. There fore I protest before Thy divine Majesty, and I swear by all Thy divine attributes, that I will follow the religion which Thou shalt reveal to me to be the true one, and will abandon, at whatever cost, that wherein I shall have discovered errors and falsehood.  I confess that I do not deserve this favor for the greatness of my sins, for which I am truly penitent, seeing they offend God, who is so good, so holy, and so worthy of love! But what I deserve not, I hope to obtain form Thine infinite mercy, and I beseech Thee to grant it unto me through the merits of that precious blood which was shed for us sinners by Thine only Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, who liveth and reigneth God, world without end. Amen.

  • A Companion to the Summa Volume I –  Book Report Part 2

    A Companion to the Summa Volume I – Book Report Part 2

    A Companion to The Summa Volume I – The Architect of the Universe (Corresponding to the Summa Theologica Ia) by Walter Farrell, O.P,, S.T.D., S.T.M.(Member of the Thomistic Institute) a 457 page book, is a good book to read by a catholic if he or she is interested in deep learning on the catholic faith. It is published By Sheed & Ward publishing New York in 1941. It has:

    IMPRIMI POTEST:

          T.S. McDerMOTT, O.P., S.T.Lr., PRIOR PROVINCIALIS.

    NIHIL OBSTAT:

          JACOBUS C. KREANEY, O.P., S.T.Lr., ph.d.

          JACOBUS M. EGAN, O.P., S.T.Lr., S.T.D.

          ARTHUR J. SCANLAN, S.T.C. CENSOR LIBRORIUM, N. Y.

    IMPRIMATUR;

          + FRANCIS J. SPELLMAN, ARCHBISHOP, N.Y.

    The summary in the inner flap of this book reads as follows;

       The present addition to the series of Companions to the Summa, originally designed to make St. Thomas available to everyone, completes the first three of a projected four volumes.  Following the same plan as its two predecessors, the present volume, too, follows the order of St. Thomas, adheres strictly to his thought, but makes use of the idiom of the butcher and the baker and the candlestick maker.

        The preceding two volumes completed St. Thomas’s moral treatises; this one opens up his dogmatic tracts.  In it, the lay man is invited to look at the world and its author.  The existence of God, the divine attributes, the Trinity, creation, the world of the angels, of men and of things are all examined profoundly, yet pleasantly, with and eye to the pertinence of the truths uncovered to the lives, loves and struggles of the men and women of our times.

        Because these questions have received so much, and so derogatory, treatment from the thinkers of our times, the book is lighted up with the constant shower of sparks that fly from the clash of modern ideas and eternal truths.  It is in this field that the most disastrous modern mistakes have been made, as it is in this field that the most sublime truths for human living are to be found.

    The contents, minus the pages, are as follows:

    THE WISE MAN’S BOOK

    HE WHO IS

    THE INEFFABLE’

    THE VISION OF GOD

    FATHER OF ALL

    THE INNER LIFE OF GOD

    THE ARCHITECT AT WORK

    THE ANGELIC WORLD

    THE ANGELS’ VISION

    ANGELIC SANTS AND SINNERS

    THE KINGDOM OF MAN

    LORD OF THE WORLD

    THE WILL OF THE LORD OF THE WORLD

    THE MIND OF THE LORD OF THE WORLD

    EVE’S FAMILY AT HOME

    GOVERNMENT OF THE PHYSICAL WORLD

    GOVERNMENT OF THE SPIRITUAL WORLD

     THE ROLE OF THE ANGELS

    THE ROLE OF MEN AND OF FATE

    It is hoped that the reader will pick up this book and be inspired by the insights it brings to to read the rest of the volumes in the series.  I later blogs I will endevor to review each of the books in the series, God willing.

  • Septuagesima Sunday (Next Sunday )notes on the liturgy and Its Significance as part of a Book Review of Light of the World Volume II

    Septuagesima Sunday (Next Sunday )notes on the liturgy and Its Significance as part of a Book Review of Light of the World Volume II

         Light of the World is a three volume series offering meditations on masses throughout the liturgical year, this book review being on the second volume. It is written the same vein as the concise “The Church’s Year” by Rev. Fr. Leonard Goffine and Dom Prosper Gueranger’s 15 volume “The Liturgical Year” and should be added to the books listed for their coverage of the liturgical year covered in an earlier blog.  The Imprimi postest and Imprimatur is a follows:

    Imprimi postest: + Stephen Schappler, O.S.B.

                                      Coadjutor Abbot

    Imprimatur:         + Joseph E Ritter, S.T.D.

                                      Archbishop of St. Louis

                                      Second Printing, 1965

    This is a translation of Volume II of Werde Licht by Rt. Rev. Benedict Baur, O.S.B. (ninth revised edition, 1955), Published by Herder & Co, Freiburg, Germany.

    Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 58-13571

    Copyright 1952, 1959 by Herder Book Co.  

         The following is a quote showing a sample or the type of meditation it offers. After some sections there are prayers to help one focus on the meditation offered in the text. This the quote about Septuagesima Sunday in its entirety. The immediately following meditation is on Septuagesima Monday.

    The Liturgy of Septuagesima Sunday        

    1. Septuagesima Sunday ushers in the Easter Cycle, and our thoughts dwell on the blessed mystery of Easter. The Easter cycle includes Christ’s passion, resurrection and glorification.  The devout Christian soul will accompany the Church as she contemplates Christ in His passion, death, resurrection, and eternal glorification. Through struggle to victory is the universal law.  Through suffering, tribulation, and death the soul achieves self-mastery, resurrection, and life. This struggle valiantly waged in this life will bring the soul to the resurrection and eternal life in heaven.
    2. On Septuagesima Sunday in the ancient Church, the candidates who were to receive baptism at Easter were selected from those who had presented themselves for instruction. This practice should remind us also that we once were presented for baptism, and as members of Christ’s mystical body we should renew our resolution to accompany Him on His sorrowful journey.  We shall accompany Christ through His struggles to victory.  Having resolved to acquit ourselves manfully in the struggle for the glory of God, and having concentrated all of our energies for that task, we shall eventually achieve a glorious victory and a blessed Easter.  Our model of mortification during this season is the martyr St. Lawrence.  We gather around him in his church at the beginning of Lent to prepare for the struggle.  Dimly in the background we catch a glimpse of the greatest of all martyrs, Jesus Christ, clothed in garments crimsoned with His own blood. With Him and His holy Church we press forward for the struggle. “The sorrows of death surrounded me, the sorrows of hell encompassed me; and in my affliction I called upon the lord, and He heard my voice from His holy temple” (Introit).  Reeling the burden of our sinfulness we cry out: “Graciously hear, we beseech Thee, O Lord, the prayers of Thy people, that we who are justly afflicted for our sins, may mercifully be freed for the glory of Thy name” (collect).

         Having made our humble plea for mercy, we arise to gird ourselves for the struggle that lies ahead of us.  The goal which we respect to reach is the eternal resurrection. But to attain our goal we must chastise our bodies and bring them into subjection (Epistle). The strength to persevere in this life of Self-denial we must seek from God, who will not deny His help to those who seek Him (Gradual).  With the catechumens let us present ourselves again as laborers in the vine yard of the Lord.  In this vineyard we shall work out our own salvation and that of our neighbor, and shall contribute to the success of the Church on earth. We have been called into the vineyard at the eleventh hour, that is, in the era of Christ, in the era of the new dispensation. God has given us a sublime calling. Since he also gives us strength and directs our labors, we can hardly refuse to labor zealously.

    • When we make our offering in the Mass today, we do so in the spirit of the willing laborers in the vineyard of the Lord.  As the paten is raised by the priest, we offer with the spotless wafer our determination to struggle against the weakness of the flesh, the allurements of the world, and sin.  We unite to this offering all the trials and sufferings that the days may being us, and beg the grace of sustaining them in the spirit of St. Lawrence and in union with the suffering of our Redeemer.

         Thus we begin Mass by renewing our belief that this sacrifice is truly a renewal of the offering on Calvary, and we declare ourselves ready to follow Him to death. The consummation of this sacrifice will not be death, but life; we look forward, not to Good Friday, but to Easter Sunday; not to the darkness of the grave, but to the brilliance of the resurrection; we are interested, not in the struggle, but in the victory.  Christ now offers Himself, not as the suffering Redeemer, but as the living, glorified conqueror of death and sin.  Through the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, he makes us partakers of this resurrection and glorification.  We share also in His love for the Father, His sanctity, His perfect prayer, His union with God: and thus we become most pleasing to His heavenly Father.  Although His is now risen and glorified, He descends to give Himself to us in Holy Communion, and shares His glorified life with us. We are now enlightened by the glory that is His, and we begin to share His glorified life.  A soul thus favored is , in a sense, already adorned with the crown of victory, and has placed in its hands already in this world the penny that is the reward for faithful service in the vineyard of the Master.  The favors enjoyed by such a soul are an earnest of the crown of victory that is to be its reward in heaven.  Through its sufferings it will conquer.

    Septuagesima Sunday

    Through struggle to victory

    1. Easter, the day of victory. The day of resurrection and redemption is already beginning. We gather at the stational church of the martyr St. Lawrence, who was tortured on the gridiron, We feel that we are united to him, and this union gives us strength for the struggle. Victory may be gained only though strife.  At Easter we shall renew that spirit of our baptism and rise to a new life. Fur the road to Easter leads over Golgotha.
    2. The kingdom of heaven is like to an householder who went out early in the morning to hire laborers into his vineyard” (Gospel). He begins his search fo laborers early in the day and visits the market place again at the third, the sixth, the ninth, and the eleventh hour.  At each visit he finds unemployed laborers idling in the market place, unconcerned about the work in the vineyard of souls.  So, too, the Lord approaches us with the question, “Why stand you here all the day idle? . . . Go you also into My vineyard.” We have as yet done very little for the salvation of our own souls or for those of others. We must now take up the task earnestly and zealously.  The Lord has given us the call: “Go you also int My vineyard,” work for the salvation of souls. Today at this very hour the invitation is given to us. For us it is not yet too late; it is never too late for any soul that is willing to turn from its evil ways and make an earnest effort.  It is too late only for those who abandon the struggle.  “Why stand you here all the day idle?”  God calls us today to bear patiently the heat and the burden of the day in His vineyard; He invites us to strive in the arena of the world for the incorruptible crown of eternal life.  We must struggle valiantly for the crown of victory.

            The liturgy places St. Lawrence before us as a model for our conduct during Lent.     While suffering on his bed of fire at the time of his martyrdom, he cried out: “The sorrows of death surround me, the sorrows of hell encompassed me; and in my affliction I called upon the Lord, and He heard my voice from His holy temple” (Introit).  A second model is given to us in the Epistle in the person of St. Paul, the valiant champion of the Church: “Brethren, know you not that they that run in the race, all run indeed, but one receiveth the prize? So run that you may obtain. And every on that striveth for the mastery refraineth himself from all things; and they indeed that they may receive a corruptible crown, but we an incorruptible one. I therefore so run, not as at an uncertainty; I so fight, not as one beating the air; but I chastise my body and bring it into subjection, lest perhaps when I have preached to others, I myself should become a castaway” (Epistle).

           The chosen people, the Israelites, provide a third example of the preparation we should make for Easter.  The thought of our baptism and of the Holy Eucharist dominates the Easter cycle, which we are now beginning.  Fut the liturgy warns us to remember that the chosen people, too, had a baptism and a Eucharist.  They “were all under the cloud, and all passed through the sea, and all in Moses were baptized, in the cloud and in the sea; and did all eat the same spiritual food, and all drank the same spiritual drink (and they drank of the spiritual rock that followed them; and the rock was Christ).  But with most of them God was not well pleased” (Epistle).  Only a small remnant of the chosen people reached the Holy Land.  The majority of them were unfaithful to God in spite of their baptism and the heavenly manna.  We be to us if we should prove unworthy of our baptism and of the Holy Eucharist.  Even the most holy things can be misused.

    •  “Every one that striveth for the mastery refraineth himself from all things.” That should also be our program at the beginning of Lent.  Why must we give up everything? That Christ the conqueror may conquer again in us and have the honor that is His due.  We must reject everything and purify ourselves, so that nothing may hamper Christ’s work in us. We die, and yet we live.  We must die to all sin and to all willful imperfections.  We must abandon all desires and thoughts that are not in conformity with Bod’s holy will.  We must die to our own will in order that the will and the spirit of Christ may dominate us completely.  This is what the holy season of Lent wishes to accomplish in us.  Are we prepared to sacrifice everything?  “Know you not thar hey that run in the race, all rum indeed, but on receiveth the prize?” (Epistle.)

            Only ”one recieveth the prize.” This one is Christ, the conqueror of sin and death. We shall win only in so far as we are united to Him as members of His mystical body.  Living in union with Him, making use of this strength, w, too, shall conquer.  That He may triumph in His members He must live in us and we in Him.  In the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass today we shall enter more fully into His life an he into ours. In Him we shall receive the prize, the possession of eternal life.

                                                                 PRAYER

       Graciously hear, we beseech Thee, O Lord, the prayers of Thy people, that we who are justly afflicted for our sins, may mercifully be freed for the glory of thy name. Through Christ our Lord. Amen. (Collect)

    The table of contents covers every mass for 1) The Prelenten Season, 2) The Season of Lent, 3) Passiontide, 4) The Easter Season, 5) Pentecost.  It starts with Septuagesima Sunday and ends with Ember Saturday in Pentecost week: Redeemed! On page 381.    

  • Part 1 of a of 3 part book review Contraception and the Natural Law by Germain G. Grisez

         The next 2 parts of this book review will carry quotes that contained adult content and a warning in the title.  This review has nothing I would consider objectionable to someone of any age to read and indeed it is merely the table of contents, the summary from the dust jacket on the book, and amazon review and some notes on the author. The book is very detailed oriented to the point that some might label it pedantic, but in my opinion is only very through and written by a professor that wants to ensure his arguments are logically “tight.”  If you want strong well thought out logical arguments, of the ilk of Thomas Aquinas’,   with regard to contraception, this is your book. The dust jacket reads as follows:

     “   One of the most explosive, crucially important issues of our day is that of contraception.  And this is the issue forthrightly examined in this challenging and deeply probing work.  The author, a Catholic layman and a father of four, is associate professor of philosophy at Gerorgetown University.  His purpose is to open to critical examination both the traditional teaching of theologians on this question and the views recently expressed by those who argue that this teaching is inadequate for contemporary man.  The author probes in detail the arguments customarily advanced to support the authoritative teaching of recent pontiffs, concluding that these arguments are unconvincing and based on an inadequate theory of natural law.  He likewise takes issue with arguments of the revisionists, and his brilliant and enlightening critique of the philosophical presuppositions underlying their suggestions does much to rid the air of specious rhetoric and errant nonsense. He then proceeds to set forth a challenging, dynamic theory of natural law and, in the light of this soundly based foundation, faces the central question: is contraception intrinsically immoral?  In addition, the author offers illuminating comments on the morality of the “Pill” and on the subjective factors that must be considered in any adequate moral theory.

        Although Dr. Grisez position will be unpopular in many quarters, his courageous, rigorously reasoned arguments will be of tremendous help to many faced with the present dilemma.  No one concerned over this burning issue can afford to miss this important new Impact book.”

    On the author:

    “Germain Grisez, Ph.D . . . an associate professor of philosophy at Georgetown University, received his doctorate in philosophy from Chicago University after completing undergraduate studies at John Carroll University.  A guest lecturer at the University of Virginia in 1961 and 1962,  Dr. Grisez has contributed articles in The Thomist, the Journal of Religion, and the New Catholic Encyclopedia.  Dr. Grisez is married and the father of four.”

    The contents page of this book reads as follows:

    FORWARD BY BISHOP JOHN WRIGHT                                  vii

    ACKNOWLEDGMENTS                                                             xi

    I    INTRODUCTION                                                                   1

    II   INADEQUATE ARGUMENTS                                                19

    III  THREE THEORIES OF MORAL LAW                                    46

    IV  WHY CONTRACEPTION IS IMMORAL                               76

    V   THEORETICAL OBJECTIONS                                                107

    VI  “DIRECTLY WILLED, POSITIVE ACT”                                   129          

    VII  PROBLEMS IN THE USE OF DRUGS                                   171

    VIII THE SUBJECTIVE MORALITY OF CONTRACEPTION         179

    Epilogue:  REFLECTIONS OF A BELIEVER                                 209

    APPENDIX: CONCEPTION PREVENTING DRUGS                     215

    INDEX                                                                                            233        

    This book is available on Amazon in either hardback or paperback. A review by Michael Pakaluk on Amazon reads as follows:

    Whatever one’s opinion of the so-called “New Natural Law,” one must be deeply impressed by this treatise, which is its origin and source. Grisez shows himself to have a masterful dialectical mind. He immediately sees the crucial importance of contraception as an ethical issue. He sets about founding an ethical theory which gives a plausible (if not ultimately satisfying) account of the wrongness of contraception, while also vindicating the reality of moral absolutes. His treatment is thorough, fairly exhaustive in its treatment of objections and alternatives, and fair. Every thoughtful Catholic should read this book, and form an opinion about it — indeed, every thoughtful and open-minded person disturbed by the consequences of the sexual revolution should read it.  The book identification on amazon is:

    ASIN ‏ : ‎ B000EIKBFM

    Publisher ‏ : ‎ The Bruce Publishing Company (January 1, 1964)

    The approbations are as follows:

    Nihil Obstat: John T. Twomey, S.T.L., Ph.D

                           Censor Librorum

    Imprimatur: + Roman B. Atkielski

                              Vicar General of Milwaukee

    November 9, 1964  

      The final 2 parts of this review will give quotes from the book to show examples of the authors writing style and will show how he thoroughly structures his answers to questions.  To get more in-depth answers with clarifying arguments, you of course will have to read the book!